EXCLUSION CRITERIA ARE NOT THE OPPOSITE OF INCLUSION CRITERIA: A SYSTEMATIC NARRATIVE REVIEW AND PRACTICAL GUIDE FOR CLINICAL AND HEALTH RESEARCHERS

Authors

A.E. Orimadegun1, O.S. Michael2, O. Ibiyemi3

Correspondents

Prof. A.E. Orimadegun
Institute of Child Health,
College of Medicine,
University of Ibadan,
Ibadan, Nigeria.
Email: beorimadegun@yahoo.com

Affiliation of Authors

1. Institute of Child Health, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria
2. Department of Pharmacology and Therapeutics, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria
3. Department of Periodontology and Community Dentistry, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria

ABSTRACT

Background: Eligibility criteria determine who can be recruited or enrolled into a study, whose data can validly answer the research question, and how far findings may be applied beyond the sample. A persistent methodological error is to treat exclusion criteria as the simple negative form of inclusion criteria.

Aim: To provide an educational, evidence-informed and practice-oriented review explaining why exclusion criteria are not the opposite of inclusion criteria and how investigators should construct, justify and report eligibility criteria.

Methods: A systematic narrative review approach was used. Searches of PubMed, Google Scholar, guideline repositories, regulatory documents and reporting guideline websites were conducted for publications on inclusion criteria, exclusion criteria, eligibility, external validity, ethics, trial protocols, observational studies and evidence synthesis. Sources were screened for conceptual or methodological relevance and synthesised narratively.

Results: Thirty-two methodological, reporting, ethical and regulatory sources were retained. The synthesis showed that inclusion criteria define the target population required to answer the research question, whereas exclusion criteria are additional justified filters applied to otherwise eligible participants, records or studies because participation may create avoidable risk, threaten validity, prevent reliable measurement, make follow-up infeasible, or violate ethical
fairness.

Conclusion: Eligibility criteria should be question-led, scientifically justified, ethically fair, operationally measurable and transparently reported. Reviewers and ethics committees should expect each exclusion criterion to have a clear rationale, not merely to restate non-inclusion.

Keywords:Eligibility criteria; Inclusion criteria; Exclusion criteria; Clinical research; Research methodology; External validity.

Scroll to Top